Compare stores

vs

Safeway vs Store #46: Which Is Cheaper?

As of September 17, 2026, Stop & Shop is cheaper. You'd pay about 11% less for the same groceries at Stop & Shop than at Safeway.

The breakdown — 7,450 products compared

  • Store #46: cheaper on 5,024 items — overall winner on average price
  • Safeway: beats Store #46 on 1,688 items — but loses overall
  • Same price: 738 items

Store #46 wins overall — but not on every item. Download Labeled App and discover healthy foods for less.

Download on the App Store

Estimated savings

  • Average prices: $5.51 at Store #46 vs $6.21 at Safeway
  • Basket savings: save about $14.00 on a 20-item basket at Store #46 (70¢ less per item)

Calculated by multiplying the average 70¢ price difference by a standard 20-item grocery trip.

Cheaper by aisle

  • Safeway: cheaper on baby foods (1%)
  • Store #46: cheaper on ready meals (15%), pantry (12%), bakery (12%), frozen (11%), dairy (11%), beverages (10%), snacks (10%), meat (8%)

Compared across 9 aisles, each averaged separately.

Cheaper in Safeway

Ingredient score C
Ring Pop Party Pack Assorted Flavor Lollipops, 15 ct

Ring Pop Party Pack Assorted Flavor Lollipops, 15 ct

$4.50Safeway
$8.99Store #46
Ingredient score A
Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Banana Puree Tubs Baby Puree 2pk 4 oz

Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Banana Puree Tubs Baby Puree 2pk 4 oz

$1.20Safeway
$2.29Store #46
Ingredient score AB
Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Sweet Potato Turkey with Oats Puree Tub Baby Puree 16pk 8 oz

Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Sweet Potato Turkey with Oats Puree Tub Baby Puree 16pk 8 oz

$1.20Safeway
$2.29Store #46
Ingredient score A
Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Banana Orange Medley Puree Tub Baby Puree 2pk 4 ea

Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Banana Orange Medley Puree Tub Baby Puree 2pk 4 ea

$1.20Safeway
$2.29Store #46
Ingredient score A
Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Apple Strawberry Banana Puree Tubs Baby Puree 2pk 4 oz

Gerber Stage 2 Baby Food Apple Strawberry Banana Puree Tubs Baby Puree 2pk 4 oz

$1.20Safeway
$2.29Store #46
Ingredient score B
Seapak Popcorn Shrimp 14 oz 14 oz

Seapak Popcorn Shrimp 14 oz 14 oz

$5.99Safeway
$10.99Store #46

Cheaper in Store #46

Ingredient score AB
Barilla Linguine Pasta Quality Non-gmo and Kosher Certified Pasta

Barilla Linguine Pasta Quality Non-gmo and Kosher Certified Pasta

$1.25Store #46
$2.50Safeway
Ingredient score AB
Barilla Medium Pasta Shells Quality Non-gmo and Kosher Certified Pasta

Barilla Medium Pasta Shells Quality Non-gmo and Kosher Certified Pasta

$1.25Store #46
$2.50Safeway
Ingredient score AB
Barilla Whole Grain Whole Wheat Rotini Pasta

Barilla Whole Grain Whole Wheat Rotini Pasta

$1.25Store #46
$2.50Safeway
Ingredient score B
Knorr Pasta Sides Cheddar Broccoli Fusilli, 4.3 oz

Knorr Pasta Sides Cheddar Broccoli Fusilli, 4.3 oz

$1.25Store #46
$2.50Safeway
Ingredient score AB
Barilla Thick Spaghetti Non Gmo Pasta Made with Durum Wheat Semolina Kosher Certified Pasta 1 lb

Barilla Thick Spaghetti Non Gmo Pasta Made with Durum Wheat Semolina Kosher Certified Pasta 1 lb

$1.25Store #46
$2.50Safeway
Ingredient score AB
Barilla Tri-color Rotini Pasta Quality Non-gmo and Kosher Certified Pasta

Barilla Tri-color Rotini Pasta Quality Non-gmo and Kosher Certified Pasta

$1.25Store #46
$2.50Safeway

Prices are periodic snapshots and may differ from your local store.

We are independent — stores don't pay us for placement.

All images, logos, and trademarks belong to their respective owners.